Who Are the Three Judges on the 9th Circuit Court Who Dismissed the Juliana v. United States case? And Why?

While climate change is an evident problem, the judges ruled that the plaintiffs, who at the time were between the ages of 8 and 19 when they filed the suit against the U.S. government for violating their constitutional rights to life, liberty, and property by enacting policies that contributed to the climate crisis, lacked valid reason to pursue change in the judicial setting. The judges also stated that legislation is the proper route to solving the climate change issue. “The panel reluctantly concluded that the plaintiffs’ case must be made to the political branches or to the electorate at large,” was stated in the final opinion.


Kelsey Juliana​, the 23-year-old named as lead plaintiff in the case, said on Friday, January 17, “​This isn’t over. Prepare for a petition for review en banc to the 9th Circuit as we refuse to do anything but move forward and ultimately win. Courts do have an obligation to address issues of constitutional, existential crisis, like climate change.”


Vox news interviewed Andrea Rodgers, a senior attorney at Our Children’s Trust, the nonprofit backing the youth who filed the lawsuit, and she said the decision is an “unprecedented and contrary to American principles of justice.”


Continuing from the final opinion, stating the Court confronting climate change is beyond the power of an Article III court. “As the opinions of their experts make plain, any effective plan would necessarily require a host of complex policy decisions entrusted, for better or for worse, to the wisdom and discretion of the executive and legislative branches.”


For all the majority’s restraint, the dissenting judge’s opinion began with:
“The government accepts as fact that the United States has reached a tipping point crying out for a concerted response — yet presses ahead toward calamity. It is as if an asteroid were barreling toward Earth, and the government decided to shut down our only defenses.”


Unfortunately, Juliana is another example of an activist case in which the plaintiffs and supporters will possibly have to leave the courts behind and instead take it to the legislative arena.


Our Children’s Trust vowed to appeal. Julia Olson from Our Children’s Trust said, “This is far from over.”

United Academics begins bargaining

United Academics of the University of Oregon (UAUO), the union that represents faculty at the university, kicked off bargaining for a new contract last month. Atop of some of their…

Sunrise Lies Down in Solidarity with Scott Warrenand Migrants in the Borderlands

…legality in the United States, it should never be a death sentence. Update: At his trial in Tucson, Arizona on November 20th a jury acquitted Scott Warren of both felony…

CALL TO ACTION: Students must strike every Friday against climate inaction

…disrupt the social, economic and political status-quo of the United States. By resisting the system of educational conformity, students can learn lessons of empowerment on local university campuses. The initiative…

What’s the Deal with Timber Industry Propaganda?

The Oregon Logging Conference has been a major pain in the neck for Eugene’s environmentalist community for many years. Nothing stinks worse for us green-minded folk than to see a…

Windy Peak Dropped From Timber Sale

…excerpts of the comments sent: “As young advocates who care about our futures and the environment, we will not stand idly by as nearly 22,000 acres of precious forest is…

Man camps terrorize indigenous women

One of the least talked about effects of oil pipelines relates to Native communities, especially the women living by pipelines and construction of them. The environmental impacts are naturally extremely…

Hunger Strike at Lane County Jail

Like many incarcerated people in the United States, those in pre-trial detention in Lane County Adult Corrections are suffering for the State’s commitment to incarceration and the lucrative prison industrial…

1-800-RAD-ICAL

…in February. Many who oppose the implementation of some sort of universal income model argue that no such program could ever function in the United States; when in fact, the…

PANDEMIC ON TOP OF PANDEMIC

…Eugene has the highest rates of homelessness per capita than any other city in the United States, and the City of Eugene has done little to ameliorate this.     We spoke…

Bernie Isn’t Our Savior, We Are

This is a historic moment for the left-wing movement in the United States. Bernie Sanders is on the edge of winning the Democratic Party’s nomination. The genuinely leftist power behind…

We Pulled Down The Statues: Pioneer Statues Come Down Following an Evening of Education

…comfortable few minutes past 6pm. A series of three speeches were given, all touching upon colonialism in the United States, Oregon’s extensive and frankly shockingly racist history, and exploitation under…

We Dropped Out of School to Spend the Winter in Iowa. Here’s Why.

…All to join this army of activists and organizers with the common mission of getting Bernie Sanders elected as the next President of the United States.  Electoral politics can eat…

Means TV Review

…available in the United States and Europe, and many of its videos are also available on its YouTube channel. Means TV’s anti-capitalism is more than an act. As a cooperative,…